Quick Hits Supplemental – E-Filing a Lawsuit is No Fun!

Yes! In their inimitable wisdom, or perhaps after a week-long bender, the Illinois Supreme Court summarily decided that all civil lawsuits must be electronically filed. Their theory, they said, was to increase court access particularly for those folks who couldn’t afford an attorney.

Perhaps if, like a gift, it was the thought that counts, you’d have to give those justices credit for their foresight. But when you take the e-filing execution into account, it quickly becomes a case of the cure being far worse than the disease.

E-File

So, with my complete sexual harassment document FOIA denial civil complaint in hand, I availed myself of the online Odyssey System only to be thoroughly confused.

The first problem is the multiple-choice dialog boxes scroll so poorly that you can’t read all of the possibilities. But even if you could, the answers are concocted in the kind of legal terms that most pro se litigants wouldn’t begin to understand.

I did correctly guess the complaint category and subcategory, but I still had attorney Jeff Meyer on the phone to ensure I didn’t go too far astray as there was yet more legalese in the offing! I did try to sue myself at one point, which would’ve been a fascinating proposition, but I eventually managed to name the Kane County State’s Attorney’s Office as the “respondent.”

But then Jeff had me upload what we thought was the wrong file, and with no way of retracing our electronic steps, I had to start the process all over again.

This time, upon attempting to upload the right file, the system said it wouldn’t accept any complaint over 15 megabytes. Enforcing brevity on lawyers? How the hell did they ever get away with that one? So, I resorted to a system chat with Shawn who told me the only option was to restart the process a third time with a smaller complaint file.

So, with a dutifully compressed the PDF file in hand, the third e-file attempt was, indeed, the charm. Here’s the stamped copy of that lawsuit:

Stamped Civil FOIA Complaint

But let me tell ya, all those bumps in the road weren’t nearly as bad as having to fork over $377.61 just for the privilege of suing the Kane County State’s Attorney’s Office.

Hey! Illinois Supreme Court! If you really want to give court access a boost, how about doing away with the kind of absurd entry fees that price justice well beyond what so many Illinoisians can afford? Granted, the KCSAO will have to pay those fees when I beat them – again – but I still have to front that cash to get the ball rolling.

Entities like the KCSAO know those fees can be cost prohibitive and they tend to take advantage of that reality.

On the good side, a mere two hours after completing the e-filing, the Kane County Circuit Clerk’s Office accepted the complaint and responded with that officially stamped copy. Now, we’ll see if Civil Division head Joe Lulves will waive service so I don’t have to shell out yet more money on a process server.

Once service has been established, it’s up to the KCSAO to respond to the lawsuit. As I previously indicated, I’ll keep you posted!

4 thoughts on “Quick Hits Supplemental – E-Filing a Lawsuit is No Fun!

  1. Next time go to the Kane County Judicial Centers law library. There is a person assigned to help people navigate the maze.

    • Dave,

      You are correct, Hailie Cox is magnificent, and I have previously availed myself of the law library. But thankfully, I have the kind of attorney and paralegal friends that kept me completely on track in the formation of this lawsuit.

  2. Jeff why is this so important to you? Hasn’t the offender been terminated? We know his name why can’t you move on? You’re like a rabid dog with a bone,

    • Susan,

      The offender is meaningless to me which is why I rarely use his name. The greater points are that local journalism still has teeth and no one is above the law – not even Joe McMahon and Joe Lulves.

      And I take the “rabid dog with a bone” depiction as a massive compliment. Joe Lulves routinely brags about the KCSAO being FOIA-proof and he’s actually proved that contention fairly well.

      But that cannot stand. A journalist has to step forward and challenge that illegal contention or the KCSAO will continue to believe, as the great Ernestine (Lily Tomlin) used to say, “We’re the phone company. We don’t have to care!”

      In addition, the office of the State’s Attorney has become so dysfunctional that change is critical, and I’m sure my FOIA efforts with the Attorney General’s Office had more than something to do with McMahon deciding not to run again. That’s a real victory for the people of Kane County.

      All that said, the main reason I’ve pursued this issue with such vigor is I’ve actually talked to some of the women who quit the KCSAO because of sexual harassment beyond just this individual, and of being unnecessarily berated by male bosses who were part of the “Welcoming Committee.”

      I’ve listened to them cry as they described being forced out of their dream job. Have you listened to them Susan? And Joe McMahon, Joe Lulves, Jody Gleason and Joe Cullen stood by and did nothing. That can’t stand, either!

      And the ONLY reason that prosecutor was finally fired is that McMahon et al were terrified that the final misogynist text would fall into my hands. And if he weren’t fired, trust me, it would’ve.

      Less importantly, but still critical, the lack of discretion applied by the KCSAO is truly frightening. That’s exactly where fascism starts.

      Jeff

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s